Home > DVD > Rip DVDs > Handbrake VS MacTheRipper

Handbrake VS MacTheRipper: Which is the Better Free DVD Ripper for Mac

Handbrake and MacTheRipper are two popular free DVD rippers on the Mac platforms. The two Mac DVD rippers can easily rip DVDs on Mac, whereupon you can enjoy movies on the go without stuffing the cumbersome DVDs into your knapsack. In view that many users don't know how to choose between Handbrake and MacTheRipper, here we list the nitty-gritty about Handbrake vs MacTheRipper review, with pros, cons, and detailed features of both rippers.

Which is better Handbrake vs MacTheRipper
Handbrake vs MacTheRipper

Can't Rip Protected DVDs with Handbrake/MactheRipper? Now You Can

MacX DVD Ripper Pro - Free download the DVD ripper better than Handbrake and MacTheRipper. macOS 12 Monterey incl.

  • Rip DVD to Mac MP4, MOV, H264, HEVC, QT, iPhone iPad, iMovie, Apple TV, etc. 420+ preset profiles with 98% quality. 1:1 DVD copy to ISO image, MPEG-2, and MKV with intact content.
  • Rip DVDs protected by CSS, region code, RCE, UOPs, Sony ARccOS, Disney X-project, etc., no libdvdcss required.
  • The fastest DVD ripping speed accelerated by AMD, QSV, Nvidia GPU tech. Less than 5 minutes to rip a 2-hour full DVD into MP4.

Rip DVD on Mac for Free with MacTheRipper

MacTheRipper (as known as MTR) is a free DVD ripper (extractor) working under macOS. Same to Handbrake, MTR has received wide recognition for its powerful abilities to rip a DVD. To be specific, it offers 4 modes to help extract content from a DVD: ISO image, Rip & Rebuild (RnR), Batch extraction, and Main feature. Currently, there are three versions available: MTR 4.1, MTR 300, and MTR 2.6.6. Only MTR 2.6.6 is free but it only works on Mac OS X 10.6 Leopard and older.

Is MacTheRipper better than Handbrake
MacTheRipper

Pros:

  • Mac The Ripper has a stand-alone DVDProbe application to help disable CSS encryption and Macrovision protection, remove region code by setting the disc's region to '0' for region-free and get rid of RCE region checking. Better still, it allows you to copy DVDs on Mac in VIDEO_TS folder, regardless of ARccOS copy protection.
  • Unlike the complicated Handbrake, MacTheRipper has a very clear manual and an intuitive interface, which makes it more acceptable by non-professionals.
  • MacTheRipper can rip DVD to VOB without quality loss. It contains the full menus, and extra features.
  • MacTheRipper endeavors to rip the main feature of a 100-min DVD movie in 22 minutes and 52 seconds, which is really a shorter period of time compared with other similar DVD rippers for Mac.

Cons:

  • MTR 2.6.6 does not work on macOS later than Snow Leopard. Even the latest MacTheRipper 4.1 only works on Mac OS X 10.7 or older OS. Compared to MactheRipper, Handbrake has a better compatibility with the latest macOS.
  • MacTheRipper 3.0 and MacTheRipper 4.1 is not free. And you have to send a gift which can cost up to $40 and finish the complex process to get the registration code.
  • Mac The Ripper can only copy DVD to hard drive in VIDEO_TS folder, which is not supported by most portable devices. And the extract media can be large in size. If you want to watch DVDs on your iPhone, iPad, Android, Handbrake is better than Mac The Ripper.
  • MacTheRipper only supports part of the Macrovision and CSS protections. Note that  MacTheRipper 4 doesn't support commercial DVD movies. Same to Handbrake, MacTheRipper won't deal with other protections like ARccOS, AACS, CPRM, Disney, etc.

Free Rip DVD Movie on Mac with Handbrake

Handbrake, similar to MacTheRipper, has a long history and still dominates the DVD ripper market whether you are using Mac, Linux, or Windows. This free DVD ripper allows Mac users to liberate movie content from the stiff disc and make it viewable on iPhone iPad without striking a blow. One of the big reasons that people love it is: it's free and open-source, and it gets the job done easily.

Handbrake vs Mactheripper review
Handbrake

Pros:

  • Handbrake provides handy presets for Apple devices, etc, making it pretty easier. So if you want to rip DVD for playing on iPhone, iPad, iPod, Apple TV, this free DVD ripper for Mac can be your first choice.
  • Compared with Mac The Ripper, Handbrake supports more output formats. It rips DVD to MP4, MKV, and WebM formats with smaller size while MacTheRipper only helps to save DVD in VIDEO_TS folder.
  • Handbrake supports GPU acceleration techs to speed up the whole DVD ripping. It is able to rip DVD to H.264/H.265 at a fast speed with high quality.
  • There are a wide range of settings and editing features to customize the output video.

Cons:

  • MacTheRipper is better than Handbrake in dealing the copy protection as Handbrake itself can't rip any DVDs protected by CSS, Sony ARccOS, Region protection, UOP, APS, etc. But it's able to remove CSS with the VLC libdvdcss library.
  • While Handbrake is able to rip DVD to other formats, it can't keep the special features/menus. That's to say, compared to MacTheRipper, Handbrake will generate quality loss.
  • While MacTheRipper is easy to use, Handbrake is not. While there are various settings and parameters in Handbrake to customize the DVD ripping, getting started with Handbrake requires a steep learning curve.
  • Handbrake DVD ripping problems occur now and then, including unable to detect DVD disc, no valid source found, DVD ripping hangs, jagged edge, poor CPU utilization in Handbrake, video audio garbled, incomplete DVD rips, etc.

Head-to-Head Comparison of Handbrake and MacTheRipper Features

Both Mactheripper and Handbrake realize your different needs of ripping DVDs. To make things clearer when you decide which is better in the Handbrake vs MacTheRipper battle, below we list the main features of the two rippers. We also include the popular DVD ripper for Mac MacX DVD Ripper Pro as the alternative to Handbrake and MacTheRipper so as to help you figure out where the two free DVD rippers are.

About the Handbrake and MacTheRipper alternative: copy protected DVD 1:1 to ISO image/MPG/MKV and rip DVDs to MP4, FLV, AVI, MOV, WMV, Apple, Android, PS, Xbox One, etc. Fast speed and reliable DVD ripping performance.

Feature Handbrake & MTR Alternative Handbrake MacTheRipper
Decrypt DVDs Keep updated with the latest protections like CSS, region code, RCE, UOPs, Sony ARccOS, Disney X-project, etc. No. With libdvdcss, it will support DVDs with CSS. CSS, Macrovision, region code, and RCE
Copy DVD 1:1 DVD to ISO image, Video_TS folder, MPEG2, and MKV No Video_TS folder
Rip DVD MP4, MOV, HEVC, H.264, MPEG4, QT, WMV, FLV, iMovie, more. MP4, MKV, WebM No
Presets 420+ presets for mobiles, TVs, game consoles, social media, etc. A slew of presets for mobile phones, tablets, TV media players, and game consoles No
Advanced settings Adjust the video/audio parameters like frame rate, bit rate, aspect ratio, subtitle/audio channel, etc. Adjust the video/audio parameters like frame rate, bit rate, aspect ratio, etc. No
Editing Merge, trim, crop, compress, add subtitles, etc. Flip, rotate, crop, resize, deinterlace, and more. No
GPU support Unique Level-3 hardware acceleration to rip a DVD within 5 minutes AMD, QSV, and Nvidia for H.264 and H.265 No
macOS supported macOS 10.12 and later
macOS 10.12 and later Mac OS X 10.6 Leopard & older for V2.6.6 and V3.0;  Mac OS 10.8 Mountain Lion & older for V4.0